Skip to content

Which employee retention strategies fit a company of 10 to 200 people?

A good employee just resigned, and you wonder who is next. Here is what turnover costs, why people leave, and which retention strategies fit a company your size.

By Surfside Human Capital SolutionsPublished 6 min read

A manager and an employee walking side by side down an office corridor, talking, a notebook in the manager's hand

Employee retention strategies are the practices that give people reasons to stay: market pay, managers who talk with each person, a clear first 90 days, a visible next step, and flexibility where the job allows. For a company of 10 to 200 people, start by learning why people leave, then fix the causes you hear most.

Your second strong employee in a quarter has just given notice. You are weighing a counteroffer, and you are wondering who is next. Replacing a person costs money and months, and the people who stay are watching how you respond.

What does employee turnover cost?

A 2012 review of published case studies by the Center for American Progress gives a rough scale. It found that the typical (median) cost of turnover was 21 percent of an employee's annual salary, leaving out executives and physicians, and that for workers earning under $50,000 the typical cost was 20 percent. At the median, replacing someone paid $60,000 would cost about $12,600. That is arithmetic on a sourced figure, not a forecast for your company.

The costs counted include separation, temporary coverage, advertising and search fees, training, and, in some studies, lost productivity. The review notes that only two of the 11 papers behind it counted indirect costs, so it may understate the full cost. It is more than a decade old, so use the percentages as a rough scale.

The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) tracks how often people leave. In 2025, the annual average quits rate in private industry was 2.2 percent a month, and the total separations rate was 3.6 percent a month. Over 12 months, that adds up to about 26 quits and 43 separations for every 100 jobs. BLS counts a quit as an employee who left voluntarily, and layoffs and discharges as involuntary separations. The rates differ by industry, so look up yours.

Why do people leave?

People leave for reasons you can often see. In a Pew Research Center survey fielded in February 2022, workers who had quit a job in 2021 gave these reasons:

Reason for quittingShare of people who quit in 2021
Low pay63%
No opportunities for advancement63%
Feeling disrespected at work57%
Lack of flexibility in choosing work hours45%
Poor benefits, such as health insurance and paid time off43%

The survey asked 965 people who left a job by choice in 2021. It is from 2022, and it is useful because it asks workers directly why they left. A newer Pew survey, from December 2024, found that only 30% of workers were highly satisfied with their pay and 26% with their opportunities for promotion, the two lowest-rated areas.

Your own people may give different reasons, which is why the first strategy is to ask them.

Which employee retention strategies fit a company of 10 to 200 people?

Five strategies cover most of what people say. The table shows what each looks like in a company your size and what the evidence is, or says plainly when it is practice with no study behind it.

StrategyIn a company your sizeWhat the evidence says
Pay that matches the marketCheck each role against current market data at least once a year, and show people the full value of their pay and benefitsLow pay was cited by 63% of people who quit in 2021, and benefits are 30.0% of private employers' compensation costs (BLS, June 2026)
Managers who talk with each personA short one-to-one with each direct report on a regular schedule, and training for first-time managers57% of people who quit cited feeling disrespected at work. The schedule is practice, not a studied standard
A clear first 90 daysA written plan for the first weeks: who meets whom, what to learn, and a check-in with the manager at 30, 60, and 90 daysPractice. No study is cited
A visible next stepLevels with written expectations, and a yearly conversation about what each person wants next63% of people who quit cited no opportunities for advancement, and 26% of workers are highly satisfied with promotion opportunities
Flexibility where the job allowsChoice in hours, or in where the work is done, for jobs that can allow it45% of people who quit cited a lack of flexibility in choosing work hours

The BLS Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics program publishes wage estimates for approximately 830 occupations, for states and metropolitan areas, which is a starting point for the pay row. Pay changes can raise pay equity questions when two people do comparable work, so review any adjustment with your employment counsel before you make it.

What performance management includes covers the manager row, and how to create an employee handbook covers writing a flexibility policy people can rely on.

How do you find out why people leave?

Ask them, in two ways. A stay conversation is a short, planned talk with a current employee about what keeps them here, what would make them leave, and what they want next. An exit interview asks the same questions of someone who is leaving.

Ask every person the same questions, write the answers down, and read them together every quarter. A person on the way out may not say everything, so give the patterns more weight than any single answer. A manager who is part of the answer should not run the conversation.

How do you measure employee retention?

Two numbers tell you most of it. The table uses invented numbers to show the arithmetic.

MeasureHow to calculate itExample (invented numbers)
Turnover ratePeople who left during the year, divided by average headcount, times 1008 left a company averaging 50 people: 8 ÷ 50 = 16%
Retention ratePeople employed on the first day who are still employed on the last day, divided by the number employed on the first day, times 10044 of the 50 people employed on January 1 are still there on December 31: 44 ÷ 50 = 88%

Track quits apart from layoffs and discharges, as BLS does, since only quits tell you about the reasons above. Then split the numbers by first-year employees, by manager, and by level. A high rate among new hires points to hiring and onboarding, and a high rate on one manager's team points to that manager. Compare your quit rate with the BLS rate for your industry, and recalculate every quarter.

When does a retention strategy not fit?

Some turnover is healthy: a poor fit who leaves, or a role that ends. No strategy keeps someone whose job you are eliminating, and retention work belongs to the people you want to keep. If the same manager keeps losing people, the fix is that manager, not a company-wide perk.

What to do next

  1. List everyone who left in the last 12 months, with role, manager, time at the company, and whether they quit or were let go.
  2. Calculate your turnover and retention rates, and compare your quits with the BLS rate for your industry.
  3. Hold a stay conversation with each person you most want to keep.
  4. Check pay for each role against current market data, and have your employment counsel review any adjustment.
  5. Pick the one or two causes you hear most, and write a 90-day plan for each with one owner.

We help you look at pay, managers, and onboarding together and decide what to fix first, alongside your employment counsel. See how we support compensation, hiring, and culture work.

Questions owners ask

What is a good employee turnover rate?

There is no single good rate. Compare yours with the BLS rate for your industry, and look at who is leaving. In 2025 the private-sector average quits rate was 2.2 percent a month, but a rate that suits a seasonal business may be a warning in a professional firm.

Will a raise keep an employee from leaving?

It addresses one reason. Low pay and a lack of advancement were each cited by 63% of people who quit in 2021, and 57% cited feeling disrespected. Ask what is driving the person's decision before you decide what to offer, and review any pay change that affects people in comparable jobs with your employment counsel.

How do you keep people when you cannot raise pay?

Pay is one of several reasons. People in Pew's survey also cited a lack of advancement, feeling disrespected, and no flexibility in work hours. You can often change those without raising pay: a clear path up, regular one-to-ones, and choice in schedules where the work allows.

General information, not legal, tax, or investment advice.

Sources

  1. There Are Significant Business Costs to Replacing Employees, Center for American Progress (Heather Boushey and Sarah Jane Glynn),
  2. Table 22. Annual average quits rates by industry and region, not seasonally adjusted, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey,
  3. Table 20. Annual average total separations rates by industry and region, not seasonally adjusted, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey,
  4. Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey definitions, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics,
  5. Majority of workers who quit a job in 2021 cite low pay, no opportunities for advancement, feeling disrespected, Pew Research Center,
  6. Job satisfaction among U.S. workers, December 2024, Pew Research Center,
  7. Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, June 2026, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics,
  8. Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics, May 2025 release, U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics,

Figures and rules as published by these sources on the dates shown.

Free consultation

Working through this now?

Talk it through with our Human Capital team in a free 30-minute consultation, in English or Spanish, with no obligation.

Schedule a free 30-minute consultation

Handled

The people side of your business, in your inbox.

Handled is Yuisa Pérez's brief for owners and managers: the people questions that come up as a team grows, and practical ways to work through them.

Send me Handled, the HR brief from Surfside Human Capital Solutions LLC, about once a month. You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy.

Surfside Capital Advisors is not a registered investment adviser or broker-dealer. It does not solicit or introduce investors, does not offer or sell securities, and does not recommend that anyone buy or sell any security. Surfside Capital Advisors is not a CPA firm and does not provide audit, review, attest, or tax return services. Content on this site is general information, not legal, tax, or investment advice.

Surfside Human Capital Solutions is not a law firm and does not give legal advice or represent anyone before a court or agency. It works alongside your employment counsel and recommends that counsel review policies and decisions that depend on the law. Content on this site is general information, not legal or tax advice.

Surfside Capital Advisors LLC and Surfside Human Capital Solutions LLC are separate companies operating under the Surfside brand. This website is operated by Surfside Capital Advisors LLC. Each company provides its own services, as named on its page (Finance or Human Capital), and is responsible only for its own services.

6 Liberty Square, Suite 2511, Boston, MA 02109

© 2026 Surfside Capital Advisors LLC. © 2026 Surfside Human Capital Solutions LLC. All rights reserved.

A